TL;DR
Turn your wind-down time into listening time
- Thousands of audiobooks, podcasts and originals
- Listen on your phone, tablet or Echo — also offline
- Cancel anytime
A 54-year-old woman told advice columnist R. Eric Thomas that strangers at a community cookout criticized her weight and repeatedly urged her to eat, despite her polite refusals. Thomas said she did not owe them her medical history and suggested a direct boundary if it happens again.
A 54-year-old woman whose post-surgical condition requires daily IV nutrition said strangers at a neighborhood cookout criticized her weight and pressured her to eat, prompting advice columnist R. Eric Thomas to tell her she did not owe them an explanation of her medical history. Her account, published October 5 by Seniors Guide, describes how remarks about her body turned an attempt to reconnect with her community into a distressing encounter.
Writing under the name “Skinny and Hungry,” the woman said a medical condition following surgery has left her needing daily IV nutrition. She reported losing a considerable amount of weight and being unable to eat much, though she said she enjoys food. At the cookout, she brought a dish, sampled some of the food and welcomed the chance to meet neighbors.
Several women she had never met told her she was too skinny and needed to eat more, she wrote. She said two filled a plate and placed it in front of her. She declined, explaining that she had enjoyed what she ate, but the women continued, including comparing her appearance to a “gangly young boy.” The reader said she knew eating more could make her sick and left before she began to cry.
Thomas replied that the women’s intentions, whatever they may have been, did not excuse the behavior. He called their conduct bullying and said her polite refusal was sufficient. His response appeared in the Seniors Guide advice column and addresses the reader’s question about whether she should have disclosed her medical history to stop the remarks.
Boundaries at Community Gatherings
The exchange highlights how unsolicited comments about weight can affect someone managing a health condition, including in a setting meant to welcome neighbors. The reader said she wants to become more active in her community as her strength improves, but worries about facing more body shaming. Thomas urged her not to let this encounter keep her away from social gatherings, while acknowledging that the strangers’ behavior was unacceptable.
His advice also draws a clear line between concern and entitlement: a person’s appearance does not give strangers license to direct what they eat or demand private medical details. The reader said she already knew she was underweight and struggled with it every day. The source does not provide independent medical information about her condition or treatment; the account is her letter and Thomas’s response.
Popular right now
Dyson V8 Cyclone Cordless Vacuum
Samsung 48-Inch S90H OLED 4K Smart TV (2026)
Dyson Ball Animal 3 Corded Upright Vacuum
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
The Reader’s Cookout Account
The woman described attending the gathering as a positive step. She was feeling well enough to socialize, enjoyed tasting some of the dishes and hoped to meet people in her community. Her account says the repeated comments and pressure changed that experience, and she left to avoid becoming more upset.
She asked whether she should have told the women about her medical history. Thomas said she was not required to do so, and that even without a medical condition the strangers had no right to push her to eat. He also noted that one plate of food at a cookout would not meaningfully change her weight. That point was part of his advice, not a medical assessment of the reader’s individual circumstances.
““No thank you. I’ve enjoyed what I have eaten.””
— The reader, writing as “Skinny and Hungry”
Details the Letter Does Not Provide
The published account does not identify the cookout’s location, the women involved or whether the reader has seen them again. It also gives no details about the underlying condition, the surgery, her treatment plan or her current medical outlook. The letter does not say whether anyone else at the gathering intervened or how the wider community responded.
The report presents the reader’s account and Thomas’s advice; it does not independently verify the encounter. No further update about the reader’s experience is included in the source material.
A Possible Response to Future Comments
Thomas advised the reader to continue attending social gatherings if she feels able, and offered a direct phrase she could use if the women make further comments. The published advice does not report whether she adopted that approach or returned to the cookout group. Any next steps regarding her health remain personal and are not detailed in the column.
Key Questions
What happened at the cookout?
The reader said several strangers criticized her weight and urged her to eat. She declined the extra food and eventually left after the comments continued.
Why did the reader say she could not eat more?
She wrote that a post-surgical medical condition requires daily IV nutrition, that she cannot eat much, and that pushing herself to eat could make her sick.
Did Eric Thomas say she had to explain her condition?
No. Thomas said she did not owe the strangers more than her response and did not need to disclose her medical history to justify declining food.
What did Thomas suggest if the comments happen again?
He suggested telling the women that comments about her body are unwelcome and that she will not tolerate more of them.
Source: rss
